American Idol judges Luke Bryan and Katy Perry shared a playful moment during a recent episode as they met musician Jack Blocker from Texas.

Blocker impressed the judges with an original song, prompting Luke to tease Katy with the song’s title.

“I’m going to sing an original. It’s called ‘I Was Wrong,'” Blocker told the trio of judges. “Katy has never uttered those words,” Bryan quipped, as Perry looked on.

Fans commented on the playful banter, with one fan saying, “Love it. Never wrong!!!! Almost correct all the time,” one person wrote. “The look she gave Luke [crying laughing emoji} the look like Luke ain’t wrong [crying laughing emoji],” another commented.

Watch the audition below. It includes the first time the judges make their vote and then change it after the hopeful leaves the room.